Skeleton Crucifix

I have nothing interesting to say about Goths. I have not been a goth and never will be. Should they be capitalised? Laziness dictates that they should not.

My 14 year old sister is a goth. This weekend, we went to a goth event.

I have recently returned to church for the first time since I was a child. It is the season of Lent; I feel it is important to go.

My sister said she would be uncomfortable coming with me because people might take offence at her jewerly (a skeleton on a crucifix, for example). This surprised me, and begs a larger question – what is goth?

As an outsider with no expertise, I can see three layers. Firstly, the aesthetic – you like black, skulls are cool, corsets and waistcoats are sexy. Unsatisfying.

Second, one that I am always struck by, the community’s acceptance of otherness – or perhaps more accurately, an acceptance of who you are which is achieved by extenuating otherness.

We all have parts of us we feel are monstrous. To my shame I have often repressed them: my aspiration to normiedom is problematic. A part of me wishes I had, as a teenager, taken my sister’s path, and embraced the strange and uncomforming.

But this second aspect is strongly correlated with what has drawn me, exhausted, to God – that, all the moral authority stuff aside, you are accepted. Should my sister go to church with her skeleton cross, I would be horrified if anyone should take offence – for this would put form over substance.

But this is not quite satisfying, either. I wonder if there is a deeper – and more troubling (for me, as a Christian) division.

Christianity has a complicated structure of feeling. On the one hand, you have God, who loves you and accepts you for who you are. All is redeemable, and in the final throw of the dice all is redeemed (unless you don’t believe that, but more fool you). On the other, you have a strict moral order. Many Christians feel fear, guilt and shame where they should feel joy, joy, joy – it takes effort to escape it (see Tillich again, for example). So there is love, but for most people a lot of bad affects too.

Is there something in the embrace of darkness? The darkness is within us.

Do we, to follow Nietzche, behave dishonestly in flying Love from the flagpole of our highest tower, because we have no power to do otherwise? Is there a power in embracing that inner diabolic (Diabolical Materialism alternative title, but I’m sure someone else has already come up with it)?

But do goths take it so seriously? For all the devils, would anyone say we live without morals, that they have no sense of justice, and that they would not be kind to another person at first instinct? From my experience, goths are neither nihilists nor Nieztchien aristocrats but people who want to be good, kind and genuine.

I am not a goth. I suspect there is no great philosphy. Nevertheless. Nevertheless.

Christianity was the religion of the white coloniser. Around the 17th Century, one begins to see those easy metaphors of whiteness being good, darkness being bad (to illustrate the use of this metaphor, see Shakespeare). It is in the text: in Genesis, let there be light!

We must reclaim the darkness. The darkness is kind to those of us who are ugly. In the darkness, our thoughts stretch out to infinity; they are not limited by the world of light.

We must end the sad marriage of acceptance and purity. You diabolists, come into the mud and rejoice!

Leave a Reply

Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
Start free